Nano Archive

What's Different, Ethically, About Nanotechnology?: Foundational Questions and Answers

McGinn, Robert E. (2010) What's Different, Ethically, About Nanotechnology?: Foundational Questions and Answers. NanoEthics, 4 (2). pp. 115-128.

[img]
Preview
PDF - Published Version
212Kb

Official URL: http://www.springerlink.com/content/130256j12w4135...

Abstract

Whether nanotechnology is ethically unique and “nanoethics” should be treated as a field in its own right remain important, contested issues. This essay seeks to contribute to the debates on these issues by exploring several foundational questions about the relationship of ethics and nanotechnology. Ethical issues related to nanotechnology exist and adoption of a defeasible presumption that such issues amount to old ethical wine in new technological bottles appears justified. Such issues are not engendered solely by intrinsic features of the nanotechnology field, but also by contingent features of the social contexts in which work in the field unfolds. The sets of factors that engender ethical issues related to nanotechnology are combinations of social-contextual and technical elements. While there do not appear to be any qualitatively new nanotechnology-related ethical issues, nanotechnology is different, ethically, from other fields of technical inquiry in at least two ways. To avoid diluting ethical concern about nanotechnology and revival of the noxious notions of autonomous technology and technological determinism, thinking, writing, and speaking about ‘nanoethics’ should yield to thinking, writing, and speaking about ‘ethical issues related to nanotechnology in society.’ Finally, nanotechnology practitioners should become familiar with the ethical dimension of their work.

Item Type:Article
Uncontrolled Keywords:The relationship between ethics and nanotechnology. Ethical issues related to nanotechnology. Unique and new ethical issues raised by nanotechnology . Nanoethics . Ethical issues related to nanotechnology in society . Criteria for a field of applied ethics to be a field in its own right . Intrinsic features of a technical field . Contingent features of a field’s social contexts . Autonomous technology . Technological determinism . Ways nanotechnology differs, ethically, from other fields of technical inquiry . Paradigm shift . The ethical dimension of nanotechnology work
Subjects:Social and Political Science > Societal and ethical aspects of nanotechnology
ID Code:9601
Deposited By:Lesley Tobin
Deposited On:10 Sep 2010 12:25
Last Modified:10 Sep 2010 12:25

Repository Staff Only: item control page